Well the story is that I had gotten the first one before she had even eaten, and when she wouldn't eat for a while after I got her I took her back so that he could either get her to eat or give me one that already has. After about a month of asking him about her and him telling me "pick her up tomorrow" and her not being able to be got he finally said, "here she is come and get her" and I ended up picking up the second pic one that he was trying to put off as the first.
Ok, so that's the story, I'm thinking about taking the second one back and asking for the first one again.