I'm intrigued by your discussion of what it takes to be a herpetologist. I'd like to play a little game with you all if you're willing to play along. I'll give you some descriptions of folks I know and what they do. I will not mention their level of education. I'd like to know which ones you consider to be herpetologists and which ones you don't. Later, I'll post their level of education and see if your opinion changes. Here goes:

1. Studies the distribution of a particular salamander species in the local area. Has been published in a professional journal. Teaches, but not about herps.

2. State herpetologist, working for the DNR. Studies a variety of herp species.

3. Curator of reptiles at an AZA accredited zoo. Studies frogs in central america, local wild turtle populations, and herps kept at the zoo.

BTW, when I say "study" I am referring to scientific research.

Its hard to say. All 3 sound like they could be herpetologists. However that still doesnt amount to much if they dont have the papers :P:P

All 3 are classed as herpetologists in my book - I agree that papers do count for something, but what about Mark O'Shea then, since we keep coming back to him.. he has a degree, but his second degree in the field of work he does is honorary,, he has years and years of experience of scientific research surrounding herps, has written many books and papers, among many other achievements. Because he doesn't have a doctorate does that make him a herpetoculturist or an amateur herpetologist??

Nice "game" Zeteki.. when do we get the answers??? What do we win what do we win?????

__________________
"If you know everything you may as well blow your brains out because the reason for existence is to learn more everyday." - Mark O'Shea, 2004

I'll go for that too!

__________________
Merlin,
What's Life Without A Little Magic!

Good one, Zeteki! I like that. I agree with Merlin and others on this, also. They all sound like a herpetologist to me. I'd also like to point out that before the modern idea of "degrees", people apprenticed in a given field to amass knowledge. The degree is just a piece of paper. I know many people who hold degrees that bus tables, and just as many who hold titled positions that do not have a degree.

Since I'll be away from my computer for the next few days, I'll give you the rest of the information now.

1. Vicky Meretsky, PhD in Wildlife Ecology
2. Zack Walker, M.S. in I don't really know what, but studied under Bruce Kingsbury
3. Anthony Wisnieski, high school diploma

All 3 engage in scholarly work related to herps and have been published in peer reviewed journals. However, Vicky's *primary* area of study isn't herps, so I don't consider her a herpetologist. But I do consider Zack and Anthony to be herpetologists because that is their primary focus. And, hey, "herpetologist" is in Zack's job title. He's the state herpetologist for Indiana.

I believe that being a herpetologist is more about what you do than what papers you have. Granted, the way things operate today you usually do need the papers to get a job as a herpetologist, but there are folks who manage to do the work without getting the degree.

Yeah I agree - your small quiz was interesting zeteki, and pointed out that many various qualifications can lead to various jobs.. I guess the definition changes slightly in everyone's opinion, and noone is right or wrong, so while Ornata and others may only agree that a herpetologist is such if he/she has the relevant papers, others may believe that experience counts just as much. No set definition.. but interesting discussion.

__________________
"If you know everything you may as well blow your brains out because the reason for existence is to learn more everyday." - Mark O'Shea, 2004

Well Microscope, you certainly got your conversation..... were your purposes served?

__________________
How many of us have ever thought seriously about eating a rat, just once, to see how it tastes?

Nobody?

Me neither.

__________________

Zane Neher.

The great and strong man is one who bears within his character many contradictions.
Crocodilian care.